Justice Department Defends Archdiocese of Washington’s Religious Liberty
The Department of Justice recently filed an amicus brief supporting reversal
of the D.C. District Court’s decision denying the Archdiocese of
Washington’s motion for preliminary injunction against Washington
Area Metropolitan Transit Authority (WMATA).
In November, the Archdiocese of Washington requested to purchase an advertisement
on WMATA buses as part of its “Find the Perfect Gift” Christmas
charitable campaign. WMATA denied this request, claiming that the advertisement
violated WMATA’s policies banning ads that “promote or oppose
any religion, religious practice or belief.” WMATA’s sole
basis for rejecting the advertisement—which conveys the implicit
message that viewers should “seek spiritual gifts,” make charitable
donations, attend church services, and pursue “public service opportunities”—was
that the advertisement “seeks to promote religion.” WMATA
accepts advertisements that contain non-religious Christmas messages from
charitable and commercial viewpoints.
In the amicus brief, the department asserts that WMATA’s rejection
of the advertisement constitutes viewpoint discrimination and is a violation
of the Archdiocese of Washington’s First Amendment right of free speech.
"As the Supreme Court has made clear, the First Amendment prohibits
the government from discriminating against religious viewpoints,"
said Associate Attorney General Rachel Brand. "By rejecting the Archdiocese’s
advertisement while allowing other Christmas advertisements, WMATA engaged
in unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination."
The Justice Department, under Attorney General Jeff Sessions’ leadership,
has shown a commitment to religious liberty and free speech protections,
highlighted by the Government’s amicus brief in Masterpiece Cakeshop
and its briefs in support of free speech on college campuses.
Note: The amicus brief can be found here.